Too much information on Sundre assault trial

Tuesday, Jan 17, 2012 06:00 am

Re: “Trial underway in Sundre assault case” by Dan Singleton, Jan. 10.

C. S. Lewis once wrote: “I would not condemn a dog on the basis of what I read in the newspapers.” Wise man. The Gazette just ran a story on a trial underway for a Sundre assault case. This trial, which is only half over, has so far involved over four hours of examination, cross-examination, and discussion on questions of admissibility. In an attempt to achieve brevity, all this was distilled into a story that takes less than a minute to read. Needless to say, such a truncated version leaves much to be desired.

As the matter is still before the court, to be fair to all sides in such a situation, the story – if it ran at all – should simply have stated, “The first very lengthy half of the trial of a Sundre man charged with assaulting his former girlfriend took place Jan. 4. The Crown called five witnesses, three of whom were cross-examined by the defence. As an inadequate time was set for the trial, forcing it to be broken up, the judge asked that in order to avoid any further fragmentation, a full day be set aside for the remainder as that much time will clearly be needed. None of the defence witnesses have yet had the opportunity to testify.”

Selective reporting on a complex matter is hurtful to the persons involved who must live and work in the same small community.

Anne Macklin

Eagle Valley


Comments

Suzie said:
I believe there was good information. I think everyone should beware of these type of people who think its alright to abuse a women and get away with it. Men like this should put in jail for a couples of years. Yes the trail has just started but when you have witness that saw the marks you can't tell me he is getting a slap on the waist. If he does then what is Canada coming too. Women should know the men who like to beat there women so we know to stay away. Dan did a very good job on writing this up. Way to go Dan!!
January 17, 2012 @ 8:51 pm Report Abuse
Forums message number 334391 has been flagged as offensive by a user.

Category:
Category 2:
Category 3:
Message ID: 334391
Post On: January 17, 2012
Posted by User #: Suzie
Posted by IP:

Message:
I believe there was good information. I think everyone should beware of these type of people who think its alright to abuse a women and get away with it. Men like this should put in jail for a couples of years. Yes the trail has just started but when you have witness that saw the marks you can't tell me he is getting a slap on the waist. If he does then what is Canada coming too. Women should know the men who like to beat there women so we know to stay away. Dan did a very good job on writing this up. Way to go Dan!!

jenna vincent said:
Well anne maybe you should be a writer? It simply stated what happened and what was said. You have nothing to do with any of this? Just a nosy neighbour sticking your nose where it dont belong.
January 17, 2012 @ 8:16 pm Report Abuse
Forums message number 334389 has been flagged as offensive by a user.

Category:
Category 2:
Category 3:
Message ID: 334389
Post On: January 17, 2012
Posted by User #: jenna vincent
Posted by IP:

Message:
Well anne maybe you should be a writer? It simply stated what happened and what was said. You have nothing to do with any of this? Just a nosy neighbour sticking your nose where it dont belong.

   
Got something to say? Post Comment!

You haven't entered any comments to post!

The Mountain View Gazette welcomes your opinions and comments. We reserve the right to edit comments for length, style, legality and taste and reproduce them in print, electronic or otherwise. For further information, please contact the editor or publisher.

In order to post comments on our web site, you must validate your email address. An email was sent to you when you registered that included an activation link. If you have not yet done so, please click on the link to activate your account.

If you did not receive your activation email, please click here to have it resent.

To post comments, you must login or register on mountainviewgazette.ca
Story URL:

Copyright © 2010 Great West Newspapers Limited Partnership. All rights reserved. The contents of this website are protected by copyright and may be used only for your personal non-commercial purposes. All other rights are reserved and commercial use is prohibited. To make use of any of this material you must first obtain permission of the owner of the copyright. For further information, please contact the editor or publisher.